Ask GM: My Atheist Daughter Wants a Christian Wedding (And I'm Losing My Mind)
- Courtney Heard
- 1 hour ago
- 6 min read
You spend twenty years unlearning the hymns, peeling scripture out of your bloodstream, convincing yourself you’re finally free... and then your atheist kid books a church for her wedding.
Today’s letter comes from someone I’ll call “Confused in California.”
The Letter
Dear GM,
I don't know what to do. My daughter (26) left Christianity about 5 years ago. she's been openly atheist ever since. I was so proud of her for thinking for herself! I left religion in my 40s and wished I'd done it sooner.
Now she's getting married. And she just told me she wants a church wedding. With a pastor. And vows that reference God.
Her fiancé is agnostic but was raised Catholic, and apparently his family are pressuring him to have a religious ceremony. My daughter says it's just for show and doesn't mean anything and I should stop being so rigid.
But it DOES mean something to me. I feel like she's betraying everything she claimed to believe (or not believe). I feel like she's being a hypocrite. tbh, I'm furious that after everything I went through to leave religion, she's crawling back into it for a wedding.
Am I wrong to be upset? Should I just smile and pretend this is fine? I don't even know if I can sit through a Christian wedding ceremony without feeling sick. - Confused in California
Atheist daughter, Christian wedding
Dear Confused in California,
I get it.
You didn’t crawl out of religion politely. You didn’t drift away like someone who got bored of Pilates. You detonated it. You pulled doctrine out of your bloodstream like shrapnel. You white-knuckled your way through the guilt, the fear of hell, the Sunday-morning muscle memory. You rebuilt your identity without a magic wizard keeping score.
And now your atheist daughter wants a Christian wedding.
In a church.
With a pastor.
With vows that name a God she does not believe exists.
Of course you’re furious. Anyone who says you shouldn’t be is lying or sedated.
When an Atheist Daughter Chooses a Christian Wedding
Let’s call this what it feels like: It feels like betrayal. It feels like she’s stepping back into the machine that chewed you up and spat you out, bruised and tender. It feels like hypocrisy dressed in white.
Psychologists have a name for this reaction: Identity threat. When something central to who you are feels challenged, your brain lights up like it’s under physical attack. Research published in Current Directions in Psychological Science shows that threats to identity activate the same neural pathways as other forms of danger. Your anger is straight-up biology.
You paid for your freedom in sweat and relationships. Watching your daughter voluntarily walk into a church feels like she’s pawning that freedom for a seating chart.
You have every reason to feel anger. But now, it's time to slow down.
Why a Church Wedding Does Not Equal Religious Relapse
You are interpreting the church wedding as theological surrender. She may be treating it as stagecraft.
Sociologist Christian Smith coined the term “Moralistic Therapeutic Deism” in Soul Searching (2005) to describe a widespread form of cultural religion marked more by vague moralism and emotional comfort than doctrinal commitment. Ritual without internal belief. Performance without depth. That gap between ritual and belief has been documented repeatedly in surveys from Pew Research Center, which show growing numbers of people identifying as nonreligious while still participating in religious ceremonies for family reasons.
What that means is that you can rest assured that your daughter is not suddenly praying the rosary at midnight.
Instead, she is negotiating with in-laws who think a secular ceremony equals damnation. And she seems to be doing a great job of it, giving inches as much as she expects to take them.
Family systems theory, pioneered by Murray Bowen, explains this dynamic well. In tightly bonded systems, deviation from tradition creates anxiety that spreads through the entire network. Your daughter is trying to reduce systemic anxiety at the launch of her marriage. She is choosing peace over ideological purity.
In other words, you should be proud, mama.
That choice may offend you. But she's showing that she can compromise, choose her battles, and deeply consider the feelings of others. You have done so well raising her. Give yourself a pat on the back.
The Rage Makes Sense. Weaponizing It Does Not.
I have to warn you: If you turn this into a crusade against her Christian wedding, you risk recreating the same rigidity that suffocated you.
Control feels righteous when you believe you are right.
Religious parents say, “We’re only pushing you because your soul is at stake.”
Secular parents might say, “We’re only pushing you because your integrity is at stake.”
The emotional architecture is identical.
Psychologist Jonathan Haidt’s work on moral foundations shows that humans anchor their outrage in sacred values. For believers, God is sacred. For you, intellectual honesty may be sacred. When sacred values feel compromised, compromise feels like contamination.
That doesn’t mean you get to torch your daughter’s wedding, though. To the contrary, here is your opportunity to show the in-laws how gracious, centred and ethical an atheist can be.
What This Is Actually About
But this isn't really about religion, is it? This is just a 26-year-old woman trying to start a marriage without igniting a holy war with her fiancé’s family.
Research on marital stability from the Gottman Institute consistently shows that external family conflict is one of the strongest predictors of early marital stress. Your daughter is prioritizing long-term relational stability over symbolic purity.
Where you see capitulation, she is thinking strategy. You see hypocrisy. She sees damage control. Neither of you is insane.
So What Do You Do With the Anger?
You absolutely do not dump it in her lap like radioactive waste.
I want you to process it privately: Therapy, long walks, loud music, journaling with some Godless Mom flair (read-as: foul-mouthed). Work through your grief, because it is yours and not your daughter's.
Then have one honest conversation. I don't want you to interrogate her. I don't want this to turn into a debate where you're wielding Hitchslap after Hitchslap. This needs to be a fair, mature and respectful conversation.
Now, I want you to tell her that you’re struggling because religion hurt you deeply. Make it about your experience, not her supposed failure.
Then shut up and listen. Listening is not surrender. It is information gathering. We're atheists. We love information gathering!
And then the most important part? You show up.
You sit in the pew. You roll your eyes internally if you must. You treat the ceremony like a language you no longer speak but still understand.
Because this is the part that truly matters: The ceremony lasts an hour. The marriage lasts decades. Your relationship with your daughter lasts the rest of your life.
Missing her wedding to defend secular purity will not feel noble in ten years. It will feel lonely.
You did not escape religion to become brittle. You escaped it to live freely.
Freedom includes letting your adult daughter make choices you would never make. Even if those choices involve a church, a pastor, and a God neither of you believes in.
Okay? You're daughter isn't suddenly eating the flesh of magic zombies or thinking of sending her babies to Sunday School. She's just compromising on her wedding venue because religion doesn't much matter to her, and she'd rather stand her ground when something that matters to her comes up.
That's all.
So, go buy the most gorgeous outfit (no atheist t-shirts) to wear to the wedding, and remember why you left religion in the first place:
It was not to win.
It was to be free.
Got a question for Ask GM? Send it to mommy@godlessmom.com with the subject line 'Ask GM.' I read every email, and I might feature yours in a future post (anonymously, of course).
Join me on Patreon for patron-only articles and content: click here.
Sources in this article:
Predicting divorce among newlyweds from the first three minutes of a marital conflict discussion
The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion by Jonathan Haidt
Family Therapy in Clinical Practice by Murray Bowen
Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers by Christian Smith
Hurt feelings: Physical pain, social exclusion, and the psychology of pain overlap.
